Britax Advocate ClickTight ARB Review

The Britax company feels that families should live life to their fullest potential and strives to create products that allow parents and children to enjoy every moment. Britax has been manufacturing products for over 70 years, and they design their products with fun and safety in mind. In 1996, the company launched for the first time in the United States after years of success in Europe with the best-selling car seats. Britax recently purchased the BOB company, and together, they continue to create strollers and car seats.

Performance Comparison

Crash Test

The Advocate struggled to keep up with the competition for crash test results. While it does meet and exceed the Federal minimum requirements and is therefore considered safe, it does not appear to offer an additional margin of protection despite the added safety features it boasts in its advertising.

The data obtained from sled crash testing includes sensor information recorded from the head and chest of a crash test dummy. Our testing takes place at the same facility used by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) with the same specifications they use in their testing for a clear for one comparison. Some of the products have test results indicating a potentially increased protection margin with fewer G forces recorded than the average product. The Advocate was not one of these options. In fact, its test results are lower than most and closer to the Federal limit than the majority of seats we tested.

The charts provided here show the test results for the Advocate (in black) and those of the car seats with the best results for the head (HIC) and chest sensors (g) (in green). The charts provide a visual comparison of the results. The HIC score for the Advocate is 388, while the best result belongs to the Britax Allegiance with a 186, where a lower result is better. The chest sensor result was 51, where the maximum allowed is 60, and the best was 33.4 for the Clek Foonf.

The Advocate has a removable anti-rebound bar (ARB), impact-absorbing base, and three layers of protection that Britax claims will increase the seat's safety. We could not locate any test data to support the claims, but we do like it when a product offers additional features for safety.

Ease of Install - LATCH

The Advocate earned an impressive result installation using the LATCH system. Its installation score is lower than the other ClickTight options we tested.

This seat has clip-style LATCH anchors that aren't as nice or easy to use as the push-button options. Attaching the clips is simple, but removing them requires pushing in, twisting, and pulling back; it will reconnect if you forget to twist.

Using the LATCH method is easy because the seat does most of the hard work for you by helping to get the straps tight without pulling on the straps. The seat portion of the cushion places pressure on the strap and tightens the car seat to the vehicle. The LATCH anchors are more challenging to loosen when removing the seat, but that is relatively standard across all products.

The Advocate has both a recline angle adjustment feature and a level to help parents achieve the proper angle for correct installation. Angle adjustment uses a handle under the front edge of the seat (above left) and can be harder to access in the rear-facing position. It has seven recline angles. The level is a ball style inside a transparent casing that indicates the correct angle when the ball rests in the labeled range, which is different for the rear and forward-facing configurations (above right).

Ease of Install - Belt

The Advocate is easy to install using the vehicle belt. The ease of installation is likely due to the similar tightening process for the belt and LATCH straps found on ClickTight options.

The seat belt threads under the seat cushion (above left shows rear-facing), and the cushion pushes down on the belt (above right shows forward-facing) to tighten the strap and secure the seat in place. This process can be done using a lap-only belt or the lap and shoulder belt if present.

This seat does not have a traditional belt lock-off, and while we are big fans of lock-offs, the pressure and design of the seat bottom clamping the belt (known as their ClickTight method) in place acts as a lock-off/tensioner (depending don't the installation method) negating the need for a separate device.

Ease of Use

The Advocate is one of the easier options in the review to use, earning top marks in this metric. The Britax products are very similar in their design and function, so it isn't a big surprise that they share similar scores for several metrics.

Harness

The buckle on the Advocate depresses without excessive force compared to much of the competition. If necessary, the chest clip can be operated with one hand and doesn't require a hand underneath it to open. We like this clip, and it is the same on all the Britax convertible products.

This seat has a non-rethread harness height adjustment that moves up and down with the squeeze of a handle on the top of the assembly. Movement is smooth and works well without too much trouble. This adjustment can be done with the baby in the seat and has 14 height options, one of the highest in the group. The crotch strap has two positions and, combined with the height options, makes for a good fit for most children.

Tightening the harness is easy with a smooth moving pull strap that makes a click sound when it should be tight enough. It is a good indicator, but we encourage parents to double-check the harness by attempting to pinch the shoulder strap. This action should not be possible in a correctly adjusted harness. Releasing the harness uses a button on the foot of the seat.

LATCH Storage

The LATCH anchors on the Advocate store under the seat on the side of the base in pockets with plastic doors. This location ensures the connectors are kept out of the way when not in use.

The user's manual storage is on the side of the seat under the headrest. The seat has a tab indicator with a manual icon. The location isn't the best as little ones can potentially access it, or it may succumb to spit-up or spills.

Cover

The cover is removable for washing. It comes off in several pieces and is hand wash and line dry only. Machine washable would be better, but at least it is removable.

Comfort/Quality

The Advocate is clearly a comfortable and quality choice compared to the competition in this review. This seat has ample padding and soft fabric on the sides that converge with the shell well without bunching or poor stitching. The seat bottom fabric is stiffer but still friendly and feels easy to wipe clean.

Everything on this seat is relatively self-contained, and the smooth shell means it is easy to keep clean without a lot of the nooks and crannies found on the less expensive products. The overall look and feel are sleek, modern, and durable.

Weight

The Advocate ClickTight ARB weighs 29.4 lbs rear-facing with the anti-rebound bar in place and 28.3 lbs front-facing without the bar. This excessive heft helped it earn a low score for weight and size. The weight of a convertible seat is something to consider if you travel frequently or move the seat from car to car. The Advocate is also wide with a max width of 20 inches, making it a poor choice for those who need to fit multiple seats or people in a row.

Should You Buy the Britax Advocate ClickTight ARB?

The Britax Advocate ClickTight ARB is a high-end Britax seat, and it does offer some interesting features like the easy-to-use Clicktight installation method. However, higher-scoring Britax options with this feature offer more for a comparable or lower price. We think there are better options from Britax and other brands that can save money or bring more to the table.

What Other Convertible Car Seat Should You Consider?

The Britax Boulevard ClickTight ARB is a top-scoring product with better crash test results and the best ease of installation scores across the board. These features make it an option we think is a better choice. If the installation is your worry, you can't go wrong with the Boulevard. If you want better crash test results, the Graco Extend2Fit offers one of the best results in the group and will cost you over $100 less than the Advocate. We think both options are better choices than the Advocate.

Manufacturer Video